Skip to content

Annie Whitaker and RJ Whitaker

Annie Whitaker and RJ Whitaker are mother and son. Annie is an unaffected carrier who unknowingly transmitted the familial variant associated with RJ’s Usher syndrome Type I. RJ’s infant diagnosis also gave a name to the clinically similar conditions his maternal grandparents had lived with for decades. Their relationship developed through ordinary family life, sustained advocacy, changing communication methods, and direct work to keep his access needs from becoming his labor alone.

Overview

Their relationship held disability inheritance, multimodal communication, generational trauma, and the practical work of navigating inaccessible systems. It was also an ordinary mother-son relationship: Annie loved her son with the fierceness of a mother who had spent years advocating beside him, and RJ loved the person who had been one of his primary guides through childhood without reducing either of them to those roles.

RJ’s failed newborn hearing screening brought Annie an immediate, almost cellular recognition of the Deafness she knew through her parents, before the genetic workup identified his USH1F variant weeks later. She did not yet know the name of his condition or that her parents’ clinically similar conditions had different genetic causes. Alongside the ordinary bond with her infant son, she felt guilt about the variant she had unknowingly passed to him and relief that Saul and Miri could share their experience of living with changing vision. RJ would have family who knew parts of the road ahead.

Origins

RJ was born in spring 2012 at Sinai Hospital in Baltimore, the Whitakers’ third child following the identical twins Lindsay and Leslie (born 2007). Annie’s pregnancy with him and his delivery were uncomplicated. His first hours were typical. Before discharge, his newborn hearing screening failed bilaterally.

The failed screening brought Annie a cold clarity. Both her parents were Deaf, and she recognized something familiar before she could articulate the connection. She signed to Robbie, who sat beside her hospital bed: ‘’I think he’s Deaf.’’ Robbie did not yet understand what the result might mean for Usher syndrome, nor did he know that he was a carrier. Annie did not explain further. She sensed that one part of their life was ending and another beginning, though she could not yet say what either would be.

The subsequent genetic workup took several weeks. Expanded genetic panel testing identified the USH1F ‘’PCDH15’’ c.733C>T (p.Arg245Ter/R245X) variant. RJ was homozygous for the variant, confirming Usher syndrome Type I. Both parents were identified as heterozygous carriers. The diagnostic clinic’s genetic counselor delivered the news with appropriate clinical care; Annie and Robbie processed it at the appointment and then went home to their infant son and their five-year-old twins and the rest of their lives.

Annie called her parents later that day and told them, in ASL over video relay, that RJ had Usher Type I. She signed the specific USH1F variant. After a long pause, her father signed back: ‘’I know.’’ Her mother waited several minutes before making a small, compact sign meaning ‘’so that is what it is’‘. Confirmatory testing subsequently showed that Saul shared RJ’s USH1F diagnosis, while Miri’s clinically similar Type I Usher syndrome came from a different gene. RJ’s diagnosis had also named conditions his grandparents had lived with for decades.

The First Year (2012-2013)

During RJ’s first year, Annie and Robbie adjusted to his diagnosis while caring for him and his older sisters. Their decisions about language and access drew on the family’s existing practice.

They committed immediately to raising RJ in American Sign Language. Annie signed natively, Robbie had become functionally fluent through his years with the Rosens, and the twins had used ASL from infancy. Saul and Miri were fluent Deaf signers, though Miri had learned ASL from her adoptive parents at about two and a half and Saul at school around five. Centering ASL rather than an oralist approach followed the family’s existing language practice. RJ began acquiring ASL in his first weeks.

Annie and Robbie also chose not to pursue cochlear implantation for RJ. Their decision reflected a commitment to Deaf identity, early language access, and ASL as his primary language. They discussed it extensively, read the relevant literature, and consulted Saul and Miri. They revisited it periodically as RJ grew, including him once he was old enough to participate; the decision did not change.

From his earliest weeks, RJ attended Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore events. He grew up knowing Deaf Jewish adults as ordinary members of his extended community. His formation as a Deaf Jewish person took place alongside his acquisition of ASL.

Annie and Robbie decided early that RJ would grow up knowing he had Usher syndrome rather than discover it in adolescence. Across his childhood, they explained the condition in age-appropriate terms, including his grandparents’ experiences and what might happen to his own vision. Annie’s clinical experience informed that decision: she had seen the harm of leaving children to experience an unnamed condition. The parents kept the commitment as RJ grew.

Annie spent RJ’s first year, and much of the following decade, processing guilt about having unknowingly passed on the variant. Her therapist, Dr. Klein, worked with her on it over several years. Robbie processed similar guilt about his own carrier status. They discussed those feelings together while continuing to care for RJ and the twins. Annie came to a workable peace with her carrier status, though she never fully let go of the retrospective grief.

Childhood (2013-2022)

From toddlerhood through approximately age ten, RJ’s changing vision was part of childhood in the Whitaker-Rosen family.

RJ became a native ASL signer. He absorbed the styles of all four adults who signed with him regularly: Annie’s broad but contained movements, Robbie’s careful fluency as a later learner, Saul’s theatrical New York–Baltimore style, and Miri’s compact precision. Early access to ASL supported his cognitive and emotional development.

The family began braille instruction around age four, before his vision had narrowed significantly. Their own knowledge of Usher progression and DeafBlind community practice guided the decision: establishing braille literacy early would keep reading accessible as his vision changed.

Orientation and mobility training began around age five. RJ learned to use a white cane before he needed it regularly. The family treated that instruction as preparation for independent movement.

RJ’s retinitis pigmentosa became apparent around age seven. Night blindness came first; as RJ began avoiding evening outings, the family shifted activities earlier. Peripheral vision loss followed at about eight or nine, and he began turning his head to see things that had once been within his peripheral field. By age ten, central vision was his primary visual channel and his peripheral field was substantially constricted.

Around age ten in 2022, RJ’s visual field had narrowed enough that visual ASL at ordinary conversational distance was becoming unreliable. The family began transitioning with him to Protactile, a DeafBlind language and set of interactional practices organized through reciprocal touch. The transition took months and sometimes frustrated RJ; Annie stayed with him through those periods. By eleven, he was a fluent Protactile signer.

Saul and Miri, both in their late seventies, learned Protactile alongside RJ. Their own narrowing visual fields had not yet made it their primary language, but learning with him kept direct conversation possible as his vision progressed faster than theirs had at his age. RJ was not the family’s first deafblind member; his grandparents also shared access practices developed across their own lives.

The Whitaker-Rosen Household as RJ’s Primary World

From infancy, Annie and Robbie worked to make RJ’s changing access needs part of household life. Robbie renovated the Whitaker-Rosen Family Home in phases, and RJ grew up moving through a space designed with him in mind. Tactile wayfinding marked floor transitions; furniture stayed in predictable places. Vibrating alerts and smart-home controls accessible through his braille display gave him ways to manage the space himself.

Annie communicated with RJ daily in ASL and later Protactile. She coordinated braille instruction, orientation and mobility training, educational access, and his ophthalmologic, genetic, and audiologic care through Johns Hopkins. She advocated within insurance and education systems while handling meals, bedtime, homework, emotional regulation, and sibling conflicts. She also grieved each stage of his vision loss while trying not to make that grief his burden.

Annie knew she could over-advocate for RJ. Her work as a trauma therapist and her experience as his mother sometimes made it difficult to step back, and she continued to address that tendency in her own therapy. She tried to let RJ experience ordinary frustration, failure, and trial and error without intervening at every difficulty. She did not always succeed; the work continued through his adolescence.

Annie also understood RJ’s changing vision through her parents’ experience. She kept Saul and Miri involved in his life and drew on the solidarity available across generations. When RJ was about seven, Miri signed to Annie: ‘’You don’t have to do this alone. We did it before you. We’re here. Bring him to us. Let him know us.’’ Annie did, and RJ came to know them closely. Their shared experience gave him family members who understood his condition from within, something he appreciated more fully as he grew older.

Annie’s Stroke and Its Impact on RJ (2033)

When Annie suffered a hemorrhagic stroke in 2033, RJ was about twenty-one. The illness disrupted a relationship on which he had long relied. Annie spent six weeks in the Johns Hopkins ICU and approximately two more months in inpatient rehabilitation. Intubation and sedation were followed by expressive aphasia, weakness, and cognitive fatigue. For much of that period, she could not communicate with him as she had before.

The loss of their usual communication was especially difficult for RJ. His family also found ways to reach them both during Annie’s hospitalization.

Annie’s acute illness interrupted her Protactile conversations with RJ. While intubated, sedated, and profoundly weak, she could not sign; when semi-conscious or cognitively impaired, she could not sustain a conversation. RJ lost a familiar way of reaching his mother for that period.

During Annie’s ICU stay, Miri, then in her late eighties and still mobile enough to visit, signed into her daughter’s hand when weakness and sedation made visual signing inaccessible. Robbie told RJ about it. He was moved that his grandmother was using the language he relied on to reach his mother. Annie later remembered recognizing Miri’s touch before she could fully wake.

Robbie coordinated the household and RJ’s daily support during Annie’s acute illness. Saul and Miri, who lived two blocks away, visited in daily rotation. Lindsay and Leslie, then twenty-six, were present as RJ’s adult sisters. Their help mattered, though it did not replace the ways Annie had been available to him.

RJ came to know Jacob more fully as part of Annie’s chosen family during her hospitalization. Jacob visited and communicated with RJ, having learned basic ASL and begun learning Protactile so they could speak directly. Jacob’s seizure in Annie’s ICU room brought another medical crisis into RJ’s view and made him aware of both the vulnerability and the breadth of his mother’s chosen family.

Annie returned home after rehabilitation. She signed more slowly and shifted some one-handed signs to her stronger left hand while her right side recovered. RJ learned her changed pace and movements. She could do less than before, but their direct communication resumed.

RJ continued processing the stroke with his grandparents, father, and wider support network over the following years. He and Annie remained close, with a new awareness of the work behind their daily communication.

Saul and Miri’s Deaths (2044) and RJ

When Saul and Miri died within thirty-six hours of each other in October 2044, RJ was thirty-two. Both grandparents had lived with Type I Usher syndrome and had adapted to changes in vision long before he encountered his own. They had learned Protactile with him and shown him lives built around, rather than halted by, their changing access needs. He lost two people who knew that progression from within.

RJ delivered a eulogy in Protactile with voicing interpretation at their joint memorial. He recalled Saul’s mischief signed onto his hand when he was small, baking with Miri in her kitchen, and the grandparents’ visits with him to Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore events. He also remembered that they continued signing directly with him after their own sight narrowed and later when his did. One line remained with the family: ‘’They taught me how to be here. I will teach my children how to be here. That is what they gave us.’‘

Annie watched from the front row and cried. Her own therapy had helped her recognize what she was seeing: RJ could carry forward what Saul and Miri had given their family. His eulogy joined their care for him to his hope for his own children.

Dynamics and Communication

Annie and RJ’s daily communication changed as his vision narrowed. From infancy through about age ten, they signed in visual ASL at ordinary conversational distance, with Annie adjusting her position as needed. After that, they communicated primarily in Protactile. Annie learned alongside him and practiced with a DeafBlind-trained instructor for several months before he needed the method fluently. She considered her Protactile less elegant than her visual ASL, but it remained functional and improved with use.

Like Saul and Annie, RJ communicated with his hands throughout a conversation. In Protactile, his hands were regularly on Annie’s and hers on his. That direct contact became part of their familiar rhythm as mother and son.

Annie also used her familiar question, ‘’what does your body know right now’‘, with RJ when he struggled emotionally or faced a difficult transition. Privately, she told Robbie that although clinical training had taught her to ask it, she had been learning that attentiveness from Miri throughout her life.

Emotional Landscape

Annie’s advocacy for RJ existed alongside grief, ordinary affection, and her effort to give him room to make his own choices.

From RJ’s diagnosis onward, Annie anticipated further vision loss. Her parents’ experience had shown her that each change could require new access practices. She tried to carry her grief without making RJ responsible for it. He remained aware of some of her worry, but she did not ask him to manage it.

Annie’s work as a trauma therapist informed how she advocated for RJ in education and medical systems that often failed disabled children. Educators and clinicians who knew the family described her as a parent who made institutions provide accommodations. That tenacity was an expression of love, though Annie also worked in therapy to recognize when advocacy risked taking over RJ’s own decisions.

RJ knew Annie as an advocate and communication partner and as the mother whose cooking, jokes, lavender-scented hair, and signing hands were part of home. He recognized what she did for him without experiencing their relationship solely through care and disability. Much of it remained ordinary to him.

When RJ was in his twenties, he told Annie directly that he did not blame her for passing on the variant, that his condition was not her fault, and that he was glad to be alive with the life he had. Annie cried. Until he said it, she had not recognized how much she needed to hear those words from him.

Legacy and Lasting Impact

Annie, Robbie, Saul, and Miri helped RJ develop self-advocacy, fluency across communication methods, and a sense of belonging as a Deaf Jewish deafblind person. Their care gave him continuity across generations while he built an adult life of his own.

After her stroke, Annie’s reduced workload gave her more time with RJ during his young adulthood. She hoped to remain present for the life he built, including a family of his own if he chose one, without assuming that his future had to follow a particular path.

Annie called RJ ‘’the person I got to be a mother to twice’‘: first during his childhood, then as she witnessed his emergence into adult life. She was proud of the life he built in a world that did not reliably accommodate him. Her pride included his choices and work, not only the adaptations his condition required.

Relationships Family Relationships Parent-Child Relationships Annie Whitaker RJ Whitaker Mother-Son Relationships